Ruskin’s influence on Hopkins was even more specific, directly touching his genius. The roots of Hopkins’ creations, inscape and instress, tap Ruskinian aesthetics . The terms were not originally theological or spiritual. Hopkins coined them before his entry into the Society of Jesus and his discovery of Scotus. He first revealed the terms in some notes he made on Parmenides dated February 9, 1868:
[Parmenides’] great text…..is that Being is and Not- being is not – which perhaps one can say, a little over- defining his meaning, means that all things are upheld by instress and are meaningless without it…..His feeling for instress, for the flush and foredrawn, and for inscape/ is most striking…..But indeed, I have often felt when I have been in this mood and felt the depth of instress or how fast the inscape holds a thing that nothing is so pregnant and straightforward to the truth as simple yes and is .
That Hopkins later integrated these concepts into his theology and that they shaped his spirituality is certain. Nonetheless, we must look for their inspiration in Hopkins’ earliest efforts to develop his own fundamental aesthetic principles. Again, the person met on such a search is Ruskin.
As we have discussed, seeing was Ruskin’s first imperative. The aesthete must learn, above all, how to see:
Nothing must come between Nature and the artist’s sight; nothing between God and the artist’s soul. Neither calculation nor hearsay, -be it the most subtle of calculations, or the wisest of sayings, – may be allowed to come between the universe, and the witness which art bears to its visible nature. The whole value of that witness depends on its being eye-witness; the whole genuineness, acceptableness, and dominion of it depend on the personal assurance of the man who utters it. All its victory depends on the veracity of the one preceding word, “Vidi” .
This facility is not natural. The senses must be trained. Uneducated senses cannot discern the truth of nature. Clearly, Hopkins took to heart and followed Ruskin’s advice. Through descriptive journaling and sketching, Ruskin held that a person’s perceptive powers become refined – Hopkins was clearly Ruskin’s disciple in this regard. Ruskin saw nature as a tutor for beauty. By `imitating’ nature, at least at first, the aspiring artist could learn what is essential, namely, that `all beauty is founded on the laws of natural forms’ . Ruskin held that if the artist can paint a leaf, he can paint the world . He emphasized vegetation as being the best of tutors in this regard. It is not by accident that Hopkins spent so much time concentrating on plants and trees.
Ruskin believed that beauty was a composition of symmetry and variety. This law of composition, so important to art, is embodied in natural forms. In observing natural forms, the artist must first master generic form. `The task of the painter, in his pursuit of ideal form, is to attain accurate knowledge…..of the peculiar virtues, duties, and characters of every species of being; down even to the stone…..’ . Thus, Ruskin’s first concern was with the `perfect idea of the form and condition in which all the properties of the species are fully developed’ . Nonetheless, because of the variations of complexity among individuals within various species (oaks for example), the artist must ultimately focus on the form characteristic of individuals, and must `show the individual character and liberty of the separate leaves, clouds, or rocks’. Therefore, both the law and individuality are essential to masterly work, but the individuality is more essential.
To understand Ruskin `it is important to note that form is characteristic not only of species, but of individuals, and that the truths of specific form are thus the first and most important of all’ . Fike demonstrates that Ruskin’s `law’ refers to regularity while individuality implies irregularity. Beauty is composed of symmetry and variety. Hopkins held this Ruskinian principle. In his 1865 essay, The Origin of Beauty: A Platonic Dialogue, written for Walter Pater at Oxford, Hopkins held that proportion is the source and seat of beauty, and that proportion is the proper combination of regularity (`consistency or agreement or likeness, either of a thing to itself or of several things to each other’) and irregularity (`difference or disagreement or change or variety’). He summarized this idea of the nature of beauty by writing that `all beauty may…be called rhyme’, for rhyme embodies the principle of regularity in relation to irregularity . Here we see a basic and early influence upon Hopkins by Ruskin. Here we begin to approach the matrix in which Hopkins’ inscape and instress developed.
Following Ruskin, Hopkins believed that form has a reality beyond its embodiment in individual objects; that is, `form’ has ontological status beyond the physical world independent of a perceiver. As Ruskin taught, the artists first task is to discover the `typical’ or ideal forms in the natural objects observed. Hopkins certainly devoted immense effort to isolating these typical forms from the detail that surrounded them. These typical forms paralleled what Hopkins and Ruskin referred to as `regularity’ in their aesthetic principles. Hopkins early on identified this aesthetic regularity as a kind of obedience to law . Thus, in searching for the typical forms of things, their regularity, he was searching for their structural law.Throughout his Oxford journal, Hopkins referred to the form or type of particular things. Trees particularly seemed to catch his attention (following Ruskin’s preferences).
Hopkins was prepared for his vocation as poet by following the method of Ruskin and accepting the basic tenets of his aesthetics. They highly refined his powers of observation and description. These aesthetics also led him to a unique appreciation of individual realities, of each thing’s pristine distinctiveness. In this `contemplative’ mode, Hopkins not only validated Ruskin’s aesthetic vision, he also created new terms to describe better his heightened experience of beauty in nature.
As we have noted, Hopkins first used his characteristic aesthetic terms, inscape and instress, in the 1868 notes on the philosopher Parmenides which he made while teaching at Newman’s Oratory School in Birmingham. There is no indication that the terms were derived from or inspired by Parmenides. In fact, they appear to be familiar terms to Hopkins. We know that Hopkins was still absorbed at the time by the Greek literature and philosophy he had studied for the Classical `Greats’ exam he passed with honours at Oxford in June of 1867.
In a February 12, 1868 letter to his friend, Baillie, he spoke of his preference for Plato and Aristotle over modern philosophers. `An interest in philosophy is almost the only one I can feel myself quite free to indulge in still’ . It would seem, then, that the use of the terms arose in the context of Greek philosophy. Throughout his life, Hopkins was keenly interested in rooting his aesthetics in sound philosophical principles. It is, therefore, not unlikely that these terms, while exhibiting a Ruskinian core, were created by Hopkins in the context of his study of classical Greek philosophy. As Fike suggests, perhaps the term inscape is a cognate of the Greek verb skopein (to look attentively) or the noun skopos (that upon which one fixes his or her look) . In any case, the essential point is that Hopkins’ use of inscape implies many of the elements of Ruskinian aesthetics discussed above. It implies unity and, in that unity, the typical form by which one species of thing is distinguished from other species. It also implies individual form which distinguishes an individual object from other objects of the same kind.
The idea of inscape, then, arose out of Hopkins’ aesthetic concerns and, as we have seen, his aesthetics were shaped by Ruskin. Inscape, in its deepest root, refers to beauty. As Hopkins wrote in his sermon on Creation and Redemption: The Great Sacrifice, `….This song of Lucifer’s was a dwelling on his own beauty, an instressing of his own inscape…..’ . Thus, Ruskin was the central influence on a key aspect of Hopkins’ thought.
There is also continuity between Hopkins’ instress and his early aesthetic theory. Hopkins used instress variably, but it has two essential meanings. It refers to the force that holds the inscape of an object together as well as to the effect or feeling produced by inscape within the beholder of a particular object. Fike connects the second sense of the term instress to Hopkins’ early aesthetic theory derived from Ruskin, namely, that instress, as the effect of inscape, corresponds to Hopkins’ views on the apprehension of beauty in an object . Through careful observation and the discovery of law and variety, or regularity and irregularity, in a thing, Hopkins, like Ruskin, held that the artist would experience a sense of beauty and the pleasure accompanying it. This parallels Hopkins’ schema whereby the inscape of a thing is discovered through close examination and the corresponding effect of that inscape (instress) is felt. Here we see the objective-subjective polarity that can be found in Ruskin continued in Hopkins’ ideas about the perception of beauty. Inscape is the objective reality that exists independent of the beholder while instress is partly the response of the beholder and partly the force of being which links the object and the beholder.
So Hopkins’ comment that `what you look hard at seems to look hard at you’ is intelligible . Part of the work of the artist is not only to convey inscape, but also to convey the moral and aesthetic energy of a thing, its instress. Inscape, then, centers on seeing as Ruskin defines it, while instress is partially the internal alchemy or response of God’s artist that occurs when a thing is truly seen. The artist `feels’ a thing’s instress as God’s plan behind its inscape and internally responds to the divine will expressed there, submits to it. Thus, art, in its truest sense, is more than faithful reproduction of what the artist `sees’. It is also an expression of the divine energy or will in a reality and the artist’s response to it .Conclusion
Certainly, Hopkins `changed’ after his entrance into the Society of Jesus and his enthralment with the person and thought of Duns Scotus. This affected his interests and the subject matter of his poetry. He leaned more toward explicitly theological concerns. Thus, nature became more and more a revelation of the Creator. Nonetheless, the early aesthetic principles that he formed, refined and applied through his study of Ruskin and, thus, of nature, remained. He refined this early influence in his two new metaphysical terms, inscape and instress. He grew to use them in theological as well as aesthetic contexts. Thus, beauty remained an ultimate preoccupation of Hopkins, but in its association with religious experience. A stanza from his poem The Wreck of the Deutschland (P 28) shows this development:
I kiss my hand
To the stars, lovely- asunder
Starlight, wafting him out of it; and
Glow, glory in thunder;
Kiss my hand to the dappled-with-damson west:
Since, tho’ he is under the world’s splendour and wonder,
His mastery must be instressed, stressed;
For I greet him the days I meet him, and bless when I understand.
Ruskin believed that the creation of beauty was a duty owed to society. Marcel Proust described Ruskin as an aesthete who dedicated his life to an unswerving cult of Beauty: `This Beauty, to which he elected to consecrate his life, was not conceived as a means of embellishing or sweetening existence, but as a reality infinitely more important than life itself …’ .
For Hopkins, before Ignatius and Duns Scotus there was Ruskin. The awakening Ruskin crafted in Hopkins was the foundation for Hopkins’ essential aesthetic. Using the philosophical and theological brick and mortar of Duns Scotus and Ignatius, Hopkins built upon this foundation to create the principles that underpinned his artistry and, ultimately, his theological thought and spirituality.
http://www.gerardmanleyhopkins.org/studies/john_ruskin.html